The Mini Cooper and Cooper S are both iconic compact cars, but choosing between them can be tough. This article explores the key differences between the 2017 Mini Cooper and Cooper S, focusing on performance, features, and overall driving experience to help you make the right decision. A firsthand comparison of a base 2017 Cooper with a loaner Cooper S highlights the core distinctions.
Power and Performance: A Noticeable Gap
The most significant difference lies under the hood. While the base Cooper boasts an impressive 162 lb-ft of torque from its quirky three-cylinder engine, delivering substantial low-end power and impressive fuel economy (mid to high 40s on the highway), the Cooper S pulls ahead with its more potent engine. The S offers significantly quicker acceleration, achieving 0-60 mph in around 6.5 seconds compared to the Cooper’s 7.3 seconds. This difference is most noticeable when accelerating to highway speeds or merging onto freeways. In everyday city driving, however, the Cooper’s ample torque feels sufficient for most situations. The Cooper’s overboost function briefly increases torque to 169 lb-ft, nearing the output of a second-generation Cooper S without overboost, further demonstrating the base model’s surprising performance.
Alt text: Close-up view of the engine in a 2017 Mini Cooper S, showcasing its powerful and compact design.
Feature Comparison: Standard vs. Upgraded
Beyond performance, several key features differentiate the two models. The Cooper S typically comes standard with LED headlights, offering superior visibility compared to the Cooper’s halogen headlights. Keyless entry is another notable feature often standard on the S but lacking in the base Cooper. While the tested Cooper came equipped with desirable options like leather, sport, and heated seats, along with 15″ wheels, upgrading to 17″ wheels with performance tires significantly enhances handling. The Cooper S often comes standard with 17″ wheels, contributing to its sportier driving dynamics. Infotainment features also vary. While the 2017 base Cooper lacked Apple CarPlay, it’s worth checking if later models or trim levels offer this popular feature.
Alt text: Interior view of a 2017 Mini Cooper, showing the dashboard, steering wheel, and infotainment system.
Making the Right Choice: Cooper or Cooper S?
Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual needs and priorities. If budget is a primary concern and spirited driving is less important, the Cooper offers a compelling combination of fuel efficiency, unique character, and sufficient performance for everyday driving. However, if you crave more power, quicker acceleration, and premium features like LED headlights and keyless entry, the Cooper S is worth the extra investment. Consider prioritizing essential features like sport seats, heated seats, and larger wheels with performance tires when choosing a Cooper model. Test driving both models back-to-back provides the best way to experience the performance and feature differences firsthand.
Alt text: A blue 2017 Mini Cooper driving on a scenic road, highlighting its compact size and stylish design.
